What do buckthorn, aphids, ladybeetle frenzy, wine-wasting, and rhinoconjunctivitis have in common?
Common Buckthorn (Rhamnus cathartica), an exotic invasive shrub, has been cited as a keystone invader of agricultural landscapes. Though endemic to Eurasia, it was introduced to North America in the 1800s as an ornamental shrub and now inhabits north eastern and north central United States as well as southern and eastern Canada. This deciduous shrub speedily displaces native plant populations and appears to play a key role in destructive invasions by other non-native taxa.
Ohio State University, Michigan State University, and Iowa State University entomologists, supported by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, are studying the distribution of common buckthorn across Michigan, Ohio, Minnesota, and Iowa. This study seeks to determine how the presence of common buckthorn relates to dispersal of the soybean aphid (Aphis glycines), a pest of soybeans (Glycine max), and to populations of the multi-colored Asian ladybeetle (Harmonia axyridis), a nuisance species and potential pest to fruit production. Both the soybean aphid and the multi-colored Asian ladybeetle are introduced species to North America.
Aphid infestations of soybean fields are facilitated by the adjacent and abundant presence of an overwintering host such as common buckthorn. The soybean aphid, first recorded in North America in 2000, uses the soybean plant as a “secondary” host, feeding and reproducing on plants during the summer, then migrating to a “primary” host, including several species of buckthorn (Rhamnus spp.), where they lay eggs and spend the winter. Though the soybean aphid also uses native species of buckthorn such as R. lanceolata and R. alnifolia as a primary host, common buckthorn is much more widely distributed, and therefore a more important host species to the aphid.
Massive numbers of soybean aphids provide a seasonally early and perhaps, a favorite food source for yet another non-native species, the multi-colored Asian ladybeetle (MALB). MALB is a natural aphid predator in its country of origin, Asia. This colorful beetle was both purposefully introduced as a biological control agent as well as accidentally introduced to North America. Through one of these methods of introduction, MALB populations were well-established by 1988.
MALB proliferate where soybean aphid densities are high, and have the undesirable effect of displacing native ladybeetles, disrupting fruit production, and becoming a nuisance in homes. They aggregate and feed on winegrapes and are difficult to remove during harvest. This results in them sometimes being crushed in the wine-making process, thus tainting the flavor of the wine, and, during once incidence of “Ladybug taint” in Ontario in 2001, resulting in a million liters of wasted wine. MALB seek out areas similar to their native limestone cliff habitat and overwinter in buildings and homes, where they can bite, causing allergic rhinoconjunctivitis for some people.
These cascading ecological, agricultural, and public health effects have prompted an interest in management of common buckthorn, as it appears to facilitate and perhaps function as a keystone to all these interactions. There are also implications for further interactions with other non-native species, as emerging research has connected common buckthorn to ten other Eurasian species and a consequent invasive species meltdown.
With this new understanding of the wide-reaching ecological impacts wrought by buckthorn invasions, one has to wonder what other connections remain to be discovered for the myriad other introduced species that are spreading rapidly to the detriment of our native communities. As awareness spreads about the interconnectedness of this problem and the “ripple effect” these invaders have, invasive plant removal efforts may take on a larger meaning and may gain support from a variety of stakeholders.
MAD Scientist & Associates